Preseason All-Americans for the 2026 NAIA Baseball season are in, headlined by five players who appeared in the 2025 Avista NAIA World Series, in Lewiston, Idaho.
Hope International (Calif.), a World Series qualifier from last season, led all teams with three honorees, including Josh Landry, a Second-Team NAIA All-American in 2025. Tennessee Wesleyan, another Series team from 2025, put two players on the 2026 Preseason list, including returning First-Team All-American Kolton Reynolds. Concordia (Neb.) was the only other team with multiple selections, placing two on the Preseason team.
Preseason All-Americans are selected annually by the NAIA Baseball Coaches Association (NAIA-BCA) All-America Committee. The list is a combination of two catchers, four outfielders, four starting pitchers, a relief pitcher, one designated hitter, and five infielders.
In all, 10 NAIA conferences are represented, led by four selections from the Great Southwest Athletic Conference (GSAC).
| Player | Institution | Position | Year | Hometown | |
| Tyler Renn |  | Columbia (Mo.) | C | Sr. | Jefferson City, Mo. |
| Camden Karlin |  | Baker (Kan.) | C | Jr. | Lawrence, Kan. |
| Colby Moran |  | Hope International (Calif.) | 1B | Sr. | Murrieta, Calif. |
| Jared Mack |  | Tabor (Kan.) | 2B | Sr. | Missouri City, Texas |
| Josh Shelly |  | Tennessee Wesleyan | 3B | Sr. | Houma, La. |
| Eliomar Otero |  | Northwestern Ohio | SS | Sr. | San Lorenzo, P.R. |
| Sam Gladd |  | Taylor (Ind.) | INF | Sr. | Columbia City, Ind. |
| Jack Kalisky |  | Our Lady of the Lake (Texas) | DH | Sr. | San Antonio, Texas. |
| David Shackleford |  | Hope International (Calif.) | OF | Jr. | La Habra, Calif. |
| Kolton Reynolds |  | Tennessee Wesleyan | OF | Jr. | Huntsville, Ark. |
| Ty Stepek |  | Madonna (Mich.) | OF | Jr. | White Lake, Mich. |
| Ty Beck |  | The Master’s (Calif.) | OF | Sr. | Lebanon, Ohio |
| Josh Landry |  | Hope International (Calif.) | P | Sr. | Long Beach, Calif. |
| Alex Johnson |  | Concordia (Neb.) | P | Sr. | Olathe, Kan. |
| Colby Reynolds |  | Johnson (Tenn.) | P | Jr. | Knoxville, Tenn. |
| Brian Ereu |  | USAO (Okla.) | P | Jr. | Caracas, Venezuela |
| Daiten Schmidt |  | Concordia (Neb.) | RP | Sr. | Hickman, Neb. |